Smart Playlist

@CCRDude wrote:

Just search the forum for more information, you’ll probably find this wiki link as well as more examples.

If only that link were on the playlist wizard…

@CCRDude wrote:

Aaah… I have it on mine, but I just checked the patch I mailed you some time ago and saw that it was in there, so it’s kind of new 😉

As a piece of information to anyone else: the link should appear in one of the next nightlies!

Yup… I noticed it too, and though “why wasn’t that there a long time ago?” So yeah, it’s in svn now, and if I ever get off my dead butt and release a new nightlies it will be in there.

— Ron

If you use “includes”, a trailing wildcard is useless, since includes implies that the search term may be anwywhere already 😉
Not sure whats wrong there though, I use “includes” on other text field without problems.

Why do you use time_modified? time_added is probably more useful if its about how long you have that music in you collection… at least I do update my tags from time to time (adding cover art & other new fields, cleaning up typos, etc.), so all my songs would appear “from the past year” 😉
Wouldn’t explain why it shows nothing though. The Wiki example seems to imply that the parser does understand both singular and plural of descriptors (week/weeks, month/months), but maybe you could try with singular instead of plural, in case this was just a typo on the wiki?

I wonder why you didn’t just copy one of the other decade examples?
year >= 1950 AND year <= 1960 ... with AND instead of && ... I haven’t tested any of the 15xx nightlies though (don’t use Vista, nor a Windows server at all 😉 ), so I can’t tell if they broke anything.

@sruckh wrote:

Ultimately I would like to use something like: Year after 52 weeks before today.

That’s: “year=2007”

You are right in that it doesn’t update itself, though. It would have to be changed once a year.

time_added does not really make sense either. If I added all my 1950 songs today I really would not like those songs to be played in my filter “Songs newer then 1 year”. I figured massaging the OS time_modified field would be easier. Is there a better method for creating this filter that I am missing?

If you set you tags right before you add them to your library, then time_modified is the same as time_added anyway, so those are really the same time. So your argument (which makes sense) against time_added applies to time_modified just as easily.

I did not see the Wiki until after seeing the mt-daapd.playlist file. I was copying the examples from the .playlist file.

There are some small differences between the .playlist syntax and the current syntax. The .playlist used lex & yacc, the current uses a home-rolled rd parser, which can’t quite support the same grammar. So do consider the wiki to be the canonical reference.

Restarting the firefly server, and the DAAP client actually did finally produce some results. Not necessarily the results I expected but some results none the less.

You have to disconnect and reconnect the client to see playlist changes. Also, double-check your tags to make sure that tag errors aren’t what is causing you to see stuff you don’t expect.

Either I have not figured out how to maximize the smart playlist query grammar, or I am needing more features. Although the WIKI is very informative, it did not help me achieve how I would like to use the smart playlist feature.

Other than “Year=2007”, what else is it you are trying to do that you can’t?

The only things I think the current playlist implementation is missing is:

1. “Top N”
2. “Order by”

There are a convenience functions I’d like:

1. In playlist “x”

But that’s it. I don’t think there is much expressive functionality missing.

I’d welcome comments on that, though.

— Ron